Respect My Authority!

edited January 6 in Rules & Officiating
imageRespect My Authority!

Coaches, players, and fans often compare sports referees to police officers when explaining the authority that a referee has over a game. While it is an easy comparison to make, everyone who makes it seriously understates the amount of authority that a referee actually possesses.

Read the full story here

Comments

  • Great article. I love the additional perspective it gives those of us that are not officials.

    My frustration with referees usually occurs when they seem to not know the rules. I was once told that an opponents stick check across my back was not a slash because; in the ref's eyes, I should've been wearing bigger shoulder pads. Whether or not the check that had occurred was a slash, the amount of padding (or lack thereof) that a player wears does not dictate a slash or not. Needless to say, the game did proceed well for anyone.
    Mark Donahue
  • scriff said:

    Great article. I love the additional perspective it gives those of us that are not officials.

    My frustration with referees usually occurs when they seem to not know the rules. I was once told that an opponents stick check across my back was not a slash because; in the ref's eyes, I should've been wearing bigger shoulder pads. Whether or not the check that had occurred was a slash, the amount of padding (or lack thereof) that a player wears does not dictate a slash or not. Needless to say, the game did proceed well for anyone.

    Scriff - I'm glad you enjoyed my article. I won't speak to the slash/no-slash since I never saw it, but I do have a problem with any official telling a player that something wasn't a slash because they felt the player's pads were inadequate. That kind of comment does not make allies from anyone on the field.
    scriffMark Donahue
  • edited January 6
    I agree 100% percent that everyone just needs to be treated as a fellow human being; this is the number thing. I also agree that the type of constructive interaction you had is ideal, and it would be beneficial of both parties to do more of that. The only thing that troubles me is a bit of blind resistance to authority could lead to bad things; unfortunately, the truth is the truth and sometimes refs make bad calls or even have bad egos to go along with it. If you saw a police officer senselessly harming a child, would you not intervene? If we can use the case one way, we should consider it the other way. Which form of authority then takes precedence, fellow human or police?

    Every game should be an opportunity for the ref to learn how to be a better ref, coaches to be better coaches, players to be better players and fans to be better fans; if it's two sided, then both parties win, but if it's one sided, there are no checks and balances. Fans, coaches, players and refs all need to be human beings in this together and search for the truth in regards to how the game should be played I believe.
    Post edited by Gregory Rose on
    scriffMark Donahue
  • I agree 100% percent that everyone just needs to be treated as a fellow human being; this is the number thing. I also agree that the type of constructive interaction you had is ideal, and it would be beneficial of both parties to do more of that. The only thing that troubles me is a bit of blind resistance to authority could lead to bad things; unfortunately, the truth is the truth and sometimes refs make bad calls or even have bad egos to go along with it. If you saw a police officer senselessly harming a child, would you not intervene? If we can use the case one way, we should consider it the other way. Which form of authority then takes precedence, fellow human or police?

    Every game should be an opportunity for the ref to learn how to be a better ref, coaches to be better coaches, players to be better players and fans to be better fans; if it's two sided, then both parties win, but if it's one sided, there are no checks and balances. Fans, coaches, players and refs all need to be human beings in this together and search for the truth in regards to how the game should be played I believe.

    Gregory Rose - I don't want to discourage the proletariat from rising up against unjust authority, but I do think you took the police analogy a bit too far. A bad call on the lacrosse field does not match up with a police officer senselessly beating a child. Now if a sports official wants to ground and pound a player like a Randy Couture fight I hope some nearby adults would put a stop to that as quickly as possible.

    I'm totally with you that each game is an opportunity for improvement for everyone involved, and if a player, coach, and official doesn't view each game as such then they should probably retire. You've given me an idea for my next post though! I think I'll write up some effective strategies that teams can use to work with the on field officials at each age level.
  • conlax14conlax14 Milford, MA
    I would say the best thing for me as a player and fan was to ref. It really makes you realize where "Bad calls" come from. While I was only reffing at the youth level, I couldn't believe the number of times you could swear a penalty happened, but based on your position at that split second, you're screened from the action. I was usually on the coaches' side of the field, so of course anything I missed in this scenario, all the parents would see clear as day. You're left with the decision between making a call that you're pretty sure happened on a player that you're pretty sure did it, or letting play go on. Most of the time this was something like a slash while a player went through traffic, pushes on crowded ground balls, etc. Either way, someone's going to be upset.

    Now while watching a game, I pay much more attention to which ref throws a flag or blows the whistle than the call itself. Many times I can completely understand why they made that call, even though my viewpoint says something different. Many times, not all. Several calls are still n the rulebook as judgment calls, so you do have to respect their judgment as the default.

    As a player, like Gordon mentioned, respect is key (humor helps too). Have you ever seen a call reversed because a player got in the face of a ref? It's a guaranteed way to have a ref pay extra close attention to you going forward (not in a positive way either) and will not change the outcome. I'll let a ref know if I don't agree with the call, but doing so politely will make sure that the next time that situation comes up in the game, they'll think about it more.

    Also, always thank them after the game. They're not getting rich off being a ref and you can't play without them. Even if you didn't agree with them the whole game, we're all human.

    Great post!
    Gordon Corsetti
  • conlax14 - Kudos to you for reffing some youth ball! You are completely correct that "either way, someone's going to be upset." One of my favorite quotes about officiating is that referees piss off 50% of the fans 100% of the time.

    When officials get evaluated by more experienced officials they are rarely dressed down for judgement calls (unless the judgement call is incredibly bad from an officiating point of view and not a fan point of view). We are evaluated based off positioning, mechanics, and consistency. Evaluators want a slash that is called on one team in the fourth quarter to be the same as a slash called on the other team in the first.

    They also want us in the correct position to make a call. Very tough for anyone to believe a borderline crease violation call if the official is out of the box. Much easier for people to accept the crease call from an official who is a step or two off the crease.

    Respectful dialogue can be improved through humor, but you need to know who you're talking to. I tend to avoid cracking jokes until the coach and I have done a few games together and we know each other.

    All you can hope to get with the officials in any sport is that they are consistent from the first whistle to the final horn. Things tend to get a little wild when no one can tell what is going to get flagged next.
    conlax14
Sign In or Register to comment.